Showing posts with label books into movies. Show all posts
Showing posts with label books into movies. Show all posts

Saturday, March 19, 2011

The Results Are In! (Poll #5)

The readers of The Bookshelf have voiced their opinions, and the results of the fifth poll are in! After reading and reviewing I Am Number Four, which is now a movie, I was inspired to create a poll to see how other people like their favorite (or even not so favorite) books being adapted into movie form. I believe it is safe to say that no one thinks the movie adaptions are better than the books, but there are a few movies that stay pretty truthful to the book counterpart. However, in my opinion, the number of movie disasters that don't stay truthful to the books greatly outnumber those that do. Head on over to this post to read more about a very fragile subject, deep and personal to me...

On to the results! The question: What's your view on books being made into movies? And the results:

  • They're great - I love seeing my favorite books on the big screen! 0 votes, 0%
  • They can be pretty good, but often don't stay truthful to the book. 11 votes, 64%
  • I don't watch them because I know they won't be good. 4 votes, 23%
  • Two words: absolutely horrible! 2 votes, 11%
As you can see, option numero dos is the winner, with well over half of the votes. This is how I, and according to this poll, everyone else, think about books being made into movies; they can be good, but only if the Hollywood puts in the effort to stay truthful to the book. Thankfully, no one voted for option number one (it pained me to type that option). Second and third place were I don't see them at all and horrible!, respectively.

And the biggest win, well at least for me, was that seventeen people voted - a NEW RECORD for The Bookshelf. Thanks, you guys. I just may have to publish an extra, reward poll sometime soon (hint, hint).

Sunday, February 6, 2011

Poll #5: Books Into Movies

Since reviewing I Am Number Four, which is being adapted into movie to be released later this month, I’ve had the concept of books into movies in my mind. I think it’s fair to say that the book is almost always better than its movie counterpart, but some movie adaptions hold pretty close to the original book. And there are those that are so far away from the book, it might as well be a whole different story.

The Harry Potter film series is a great example of how a movie can be truthful to the book. They’re not entirely the same, but awfully close. And with the release of the last Harry Potter movie this year, Harry Potter and Deathly Hallows Part II, it’s going to be sad to know that there probably won’t be any more truthful and accurate adaptions for a while.

A good, or bad, example of bad movie adaptions of books is last year’s release of Percy Jackson and the Olympians: The Lightning Thief. I really shouldn’t talk about this because I’ll just rant on forever, never stopping. Let’s just say I, and millions of others, were greatly upset by the direction they took with the film. And it shows in the critics’ reviews, too. What was really upsetting was that it was directed by Chris Columbus, the same guy that directed the first two Harry Potter films and produced the third (however, he did not discover the New World). I just guess I expected more.

So, you get what I’m saying? Books into movies can be really good or really bad. And I suppose I can see why; most move scripts are 90-175 pages, not like books which are, typically, 250-800 pages. Also, movie producers want to try to make the story their own, unique and special, so I can see how that would cause some changes in the movies, too.

Anyways, let’s get to the main point of this post: the unveiling of a new poll! This is the fifth poll on The Bookshelf, and it’s about the adaption of books into movies and what you, the readers of The Bookshelf, think about them. The poll, as usual, is located on the right side of the page, under the “about me” section. Please, please, please vote! There’s no reason not to – you don’t have to be eighteen to vote here! So far there’s no official, set in concrete, poll closing date yet, but I’m thinking maybe March 12th?

To thank you for reading this unnecessarily too long post, I have included some info about upcoming books into movies release dates in 2011:

I Am Number Four, Feb. 18

Beastly, March 4

Water for Elephants, April 22

Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows Part II, July 15

The Help, Aug. 12

Twilight Saga: Breaking Dawn Part I, Nov. 18

Hugo Cabret, Dec. 9

The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo, Dec. 21 (this is actually the second adaptation of this book)

...

And just because I’m excited about this one,

The Hunger Games, March 23, 2012!

I cannot wait for The Hunger Games movie, if you can’t tell.

Well that’s it, now go vote!

I Am Number Four: A Mysterious Thrill Ride

Numerous things caused me to pick up this book, I Am Number Four by Pittacus Lore, at my local bookstore a week ago: 1) There is a movie adaption, also titled I Am Number Four, of it coming out later this month; 2) This book is written under a pseudonym; 3) The actual author, or rather authors, of this book are, Jobie Hughes and James Frey, the latter of which is the controversial author of a fabricated memoir, A Million Little Pieces; 4) This book is very well designed, with a cool cover and interesting typeface and icons inside; 5) I was intrigued by the title, I Am Number Four, which is actually part of a sentence, Three are dead, I am number four. So, knowing these things, I began reading what was sure to be either a big success or a big flop.

I Am Number Four begin with the death of Number Three, one of nine aliens from the planet Lorien that escaped to Earth ten years ago after their planet was destroyed. The planet Lorien was taken over by the Mogadorians, another race of alien, in search of a life-sustaining planet. Number Four, then known as Daniel Jones, knew of Number Three’s death because of a curse that was put upon him and the eight others before departing Lorien at age four. The Mogadorians are out to destroy what is remaining of the people of Lorien, however, due to the curse, they must kill each Lorien in sequential order, one through nine. Each of the nine Loriens are aware of when their fellow allies die, because a small scar forms around their ankle each time one dies.

Upon feeling the third scar form around his ankle, Number Four, a member of the Garde, an elite form of Loriens that at a certain age will develop many supernatural abilities, and his Cepan, a keeper and protector of the Garde, Henri, flee their current home in Florida. They settle down in middle-of-nowhere Paradise, Ohio and start creating a new life. Henri, who is a fatherly figure to Number Four, helps him create a new identity. Number Four is then enrolled in high school and begins to go by the name John Smith.

For his entire life on Earth, almost his whole life, Number Four, John, is taught to not get to connected or involved with his home, his belongings, his town, and the people that live there. This is standard for procedure for John. He is used to leaving at a moment’s notice without even saying goodbye. He understands that if he actually made a true relationship with the people around him, he would be greatly hurt when he would have to leave. So, John starts his first day of school with hope that he’ll do what he’s supposed to do, then go home. Nothing more.

Unfortunately, that doesn’t happen. After receiving a warm welcome from the friendly Sarah Hart, John is taunted and teased by Mark James, her big, jock, ex-boyfriend. After standing up to Mark, John is befriended by Sam Goode, a fellow outcast and space/extraterrestrial beings nerd. John’s plan for no connections with the people around him had gone down the drain. Not to mention, he got his first power, known as a Legacy, the ability to shine light from his hands. All on his first day in Ohio.

The book progresses, with many plot twists and raging emotions: John and Sarah beginning dating, John and Sam becoming best friends, Henri training John to control and properly use his Legacies, and the ever constant threat of the Mogadorians finding Number Four. Ultimately, this book leads to a breath-taking cliffhanger ending, that will lead readers doubled over, waiting for the sequel, The Power of Six, coming out in August. This was, overall, a great first book. It set the scene for many good, potentially even better, sequels to come. My only complaint was that at times the characters seemed bland and two dimensional. This book could have been excellent if it took more time to better explain the feelings of the characters and how they reacted. But it was, overall, a great read.

Rating: 4.25 out of 5 stars